(An Open Letter)
By Mara Vale
Mara Vale is a pseudonym used to protect the author’s privacy. In this essay, she writes about what happens when women speak up and how institutions respond.

Image Credit – ABC News/Matt Roberts
To everyone who has spent this week hunting for the “real story” behind the allegations against Senator Jordon Steele-John, I have read your theories. “It was One Nation and the Liberals.” “It was Labor, getting even over a Senate amendment.” “It was Mehreen Faruqi,” a claim that says far more about the racism of the people repeating it than it does about her. “It was Sophie McNeill and her ‘cabal’ running a preselection play against a woman named in the reporting.” Each version is more elaborate than the last. But they’re all doing the same thing: moving our attention away from the women at the centre of this.
So let me offer the simplest explanation. A group of current and former party members wrote a letter. Seven of them signed it. Many more wanted to sign it but were too afraid. They put their names to it knowing it could cost them their reputations, their jobs, their futures and their safety, with the very real threat of legal action hanging over them. The letter says that for every person who signed, several more were too frightened to. That is Occam’s razor. People came forward because they believe something happened to women in the party and community, more than once, over many years.

Image Credit- The Greens Website
What the institution did
You don’t need to decide whether the Senator is guilty to see what happened inside the party. He denies the allegations, as people accused always do. The reporting describes how an institution responded when women raised concerns.

According to the Sydney Morning Herald, a 47-page crisis communications manual was first drafted in 2016 and kept for close to a decade. Greens WA has confirmed it is authentic. It set out stock lines for journalists. It recast two women’s complaints as “a dispute of an interpersonal nature”. It tasked staff with monitoring party members who discussed the allegations online and screenshotting their posts. A senior office bearer resigned in 2017 over how it was handled. In 2018, minutes from a state Young Greens meeting directed delegates to defer, and if necessary block, proposals for a formal investigation into sexual harassment claims.
That is how institutional silence works. Usually nobody has to lie outright. It is built from talking points and careful wording, from watching the people who speak up, and from quietly deciding that the organisation’s reputation comes first. We have watched churches, sporting clubs, universities and Parliament House do exactly this. We were right to condemn them. We cannot pretend a progressive movement is immune, simply because it’s progressive.
Why women don’t report
Fewer than 8% of women sexually assaulted by a man in the decade to 2021–22 reported the most recent incident to police. Women tell researchers that they expect not to be believed, they fear retaliation, and they have watched what happens to the women who go first. False reports are estimated at between 2% and 10% of reported cases, and that is a very generous estimate.

Every post claiming this is a coordinated hit is being read by a woman somewhere who is weighing whether to speak up about her own workplace, her own party or her own partner. This week she has learned exactly what she can expect. Her account will be called a plot. Other women will be blamed for it. She herself will be treated as a pawn in someone else’s game. That is the harm these theories cause, and it falls on women who have nothing to do with factional politics.
I have seen almost nobody express care for the people who came forward, or gratitude for what it cost them. That silence speaks too.
“One of our own”
This is the hard part for the left. It is more comfortable to blame women, whether that’s Mehreen, Sophie or some imagined cabal, than to sit with the possibility that a man who shares our values could also be a man who harmed women. Men’s violence against women and children doesn’t check party membership. A strong voting record is no character reference. A character reference in general is useless – because if you have allegations against you, you’re probably not of good character. If our politics only takes allegations seriously when they’re made against our opponents, we’re defending our team rather than believing women.
Senator Steele-John’s advocacy for disabled people has mattered to a great many people, and I understand why parts of the disability community feel protective of him. Ableism is real and it deserves to be named wherever it shows up. Women with disability also experience sexual violence at higher rates than other women. Disabled women deserve a party that takes these allegations seriously.
“It’s he said, she said”
Yes, it is. It almost always is. Men’s violence rarely has witnesses, which is why so few cases ever reach a courtroom and so few of those end in a conviction. If our threshold for acting is a criminal conviction, we have chosen to act almost never.
Not convicted does not mean not guilty.
A political party has a different job from a court. Its job is to make sure the people in its rooms are safe, and every workplace in this country decides that on the balance of probabilities. One allegation is a chance. Two is a coincidence. Three is a pattern. The grievance letter describes allegations spanning almost a decade. That should be more than enough for an investigation to lead to real action.
On “fair”
Everyone is suddenly calling for a fair process. Good. I want one too. So ask yourself whether the women at the centre of this were treated fairly. Was it fair when their complaint was reworded into an interpersonal dispute? Was it fair when the members who talked about it were monitored? Is it fair when a woman goes to the police and waits months to hear anything about her own case?

A fair process this time means an investigator with no ties to anyone who handled these matters before. Its terms of reference must cover how the party handled them. Anyone who comes forward needs protection from retaliation. The findings must be made public. Anything short of that is the same system protecting itself again.
Image Credit – David Shoebridge/Campaign Portrait, 2022
In the words of Senator Larissa Waters: “We cannot expect women to report if we do not make it safe for them to do so.”
Greens leader David Shoebridge recently asked men to “demand better from our mates, our team, our colleagues.”
This is me demanding better from mine.